Huge debate and fixture delay as Fylde RFC grapple with ‘The Cheshire Problem’
Fylde RFC finally know the 13 clubs they will face in National Two North next season … but only after a long and difficult debate involving the Rugby Football Union and fellow clubs in the fourth tier of the English game.
After an imperfect settlement which finally enables fixture lists to be compiled for 2026/27, just about the only point unanimously agreed is that a rethink is needed when the RFU reviews its league structure next season.


The upshot of a meeting between the 16 northern clubs at level four is that Macclesfield have resigned their place, preferring to play in a regional competition than in National Two West, which includes five clubs from Cornwall, Devon and Somerset.
The issue is that level four is divided into three leagues of 14, meaning there are two northern clubs too many for National Two North.
As the rest of the country is split into East and West leagues, the two surplus north-west clubs were thrown in with the south-west sides.
And although the RFU insists its decisions have been based on '”lowest total mileage calculations”, Macclesfield would still have faced a 640-mile round trip to play Redruth.
Chairman of rugby Mark Nelson and club chairman Matt Thompson represented Fylde at the meeting and Nelson told The Gazette: “This has become known as the 'The Cheshire Problem' and we can't find a solution.
“There aren't enough Midlands clubs to split the leagues into North-Midlands-South, and they can't populate a West league without sucking Cheshire in.
“Clubs like Macclesfield and Lymm are talking north of £25,000 just in travel expenses to the Devon and Cornwall peninsula.
“There are hotel costs too because they can't travel down there on the morning of a game and the RFU won't give financial support.
“We said we'd go up to 16 in Two North to embrace Macclesfield and Lymm but the RFU want play-offs and won't go above 26 games in the regular season.
“Matt and I did our level best to find a solution and I was talking to people for three days trying to sort something out, but the RFU have retained their original decision.
“I think they will have to look at reformatting and the season may have to go back to 30 games.”
Chester return to Two North for 2026/27, though Lymm must look forward to another season in Two West and another 4,500 miles on the road.
Chester are among five changes to Fylde's competition for next season. They are joined by relegated Sedgley Park and three promoted clubs from Regional 1: Huddersfield (North West champions), Heath (North East champs, from Halifax) and play-off winners Harrogate.
Those five replace promoted Sheffield, relegated Hull and Scunthorpe, play-off losers Rossendale and of course Macclesfield, whose drop to Regional 1 means Loughborough Students are spared relegation from Two West.
National League Rugby chairman John Inverdale said: “It is extremely sad that Macclesfield have made the decision they have but we understand their reasons.
“Playing in the National Leagues is prestigious and aspirational but ultimately an expensive operation. It’s hoped this hugely complex and long drawn-out debate can lead to a rethink on how Level 4 and below is configured in the future.”
The RFU also thanked clubs for their patience over next season's fixtures, which Nelson hopes will be released next week.
National Two North 2026/27: Billingham, Chester, Darlington Mowden Park, Fylde, Harrogate, Heath, Huddersfield, Hull Ionians, Otley, Preston Grasshoppers, Sedgley Park, Sheffield Tigers, Tynedale, Wharfedale.