Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Blackpool Unlimited
Support, advice and information for local businesses
seeking opportunities in the new Blackpool.
 
 
Monday, 12th May 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Blackpool Gazette site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Smoking ban rebel in court again



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

REBEL landlord Hamish Howitt has failed in his bid to use human rights laws to defend himself after allowing smoking in his bar.
Howitt, 55, of the Happy Scots Bar on Rigby Road, Blackpool became the first publican in England to be convicted for breaching the smoking ban legislation last November.

He appeared in court again yesterday after receiving further summonses from Blackpool Council for continuing to flout the ban.

Preston Magistrates' Court was told that officers from Blackpool Council visited the bar on five separate occasions last November – the first time just two days after he was fined £500 for letting his regulars light up.

Each time the bar was thick with smoke and customers were spotted smoking in full view of staff who did nothing to stop them, the court heard.

Representing himself, Howitt, who denied the charges claiming the laws breached human rights, said: "It is an oppressive law.

"It is affecting my business. I am on the verge of bankruptcy.

"The Health Act 2006 is not proportionate. Smokers should be given a life as well as non-smokers.

"I'm having to push blind people and those in wheelchairs out into the street."

Disagreed

Howitt argued he should be exempt from the law because his premises were not public, as he ultimately decided who was allowed in, and he said there was no proof that smoking itself killed.

District Judge Michael Singleton disagreed and convicted him of five counts of failing to enforce the ban.

He said: "The defendant asserts that the Health Act 2006 and its enforcement are in breach of the Human Rights Act 1998.

"In my view it is not in breach of that act or any articles under the European Convention of Human Rights. He has asserted the premises are not open to the public but I am satisfied they are."

Howitt was fined £250 for each of the five counts of flouting the ban and £100 each for breaching seven separate conditional discharges imposed at the last hearing in November, £2,000 prosecution costs and a £15 victims' surcharge to the court.

Mr Singleton warned him he could face prison if he did not pay the monies owed within 28 days.

Outside court, Howitt confirmed he was preparing to take the case to the High Court to seek a judicial review.

Howitt has been a staunch critic of the ban and has even set up a political party named Fight Against Government Suppression (Fags).

He has since renamed his pub, The Freed Inn 2 Choose.

The full article contains 429 words and appears in Blackpool Gazette newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 March 2008 11:47 AM
  • Source: Blackpool Gazette
  • Location: Blackpool
 
Prev
1
2 3 4 5 6 7
1

Ann-Marie Connor,

Blackpool 27/03/2008 08:01:28
I am in full support of Hamish Howitt. There is no proof that passive smoking kills, this is all propaganda and car exhaust fumes do far more damage to people. France, Belgium, Spain have all ignored the no smoking ban and smokers can still enjoy a cigarette and a pint in a bar over there, where they are civilized and have the freedom of choice to smoke or not to smoke in the smoking rooms provided. What will be banned next!!!! in this nanny state called Britain?
2

100%Blackpool,

27/03/2008 08:08:28
I dont believe that in Parliament bars the staff walk around saying 'please would you smoke that huge cigar paid for by public money outside as if everybody in this bar was to sit here and breathe in your smoke for 20 years they may possibly become ill'!
What a load of rubbish!!
Our troops are being forced to fight stupid wars that have nothing to do with us with sub standard equipment while their Government, rather that support them is sitting back and passing stupid laws like the smoking ban!!!
While on a rant who's stupid idea was it to secure Britain's identity by changing the national anthem? Is that not changing the identity
3

Frustrated,

St Annes 27/03/2008 08:47:39
You have your heads in the sand if you don't believe that passive smoking kills. My dad died of lung cancer having never smoked himself but having a father that did at home and then bosses at work that did.

However the ban does not allow those who actively choose to ignore this or are smokers themselves to indulge with what is still a legal activity. A much better solution would be to allow a small number of bars and pubs for smokers and charge a licence fee for so doing.
And this victim's surcharge is ridiculous. There are no unwilling victims of Mr Howitt's refusal to impose the ban.
4

Simonr85,

Preston 27/03/2008 10:11:35
Im in full support of Hamish, he doesnt even smoke himself and neither do i, and the people that do its there own choice so they should be allowed, ive worked in pubs before and yes its smokey but if it was a problem for me then i would just get a job elsewhere, they say its to protect staff but why get a job in a smokey atmosphere if you dont like it!

Another thing is that people who go in Hamishs bar will and have smoked for years so why stop them, if they didnt like it, go somewhere else.

This country is a joke!
5

disgusted NANAOF5@BTINTERNET.COM,

27/03/2008 10:26:19
whatever next ; a ban on cream cakes ; certain aisles in supermarkets for fat and thin people ;walk down left hand side of pavement ;Hamish Howett has GUTS and i believe in what hes doing ; this used to be GREAT BRITAIN ; WHAT HAPPENED ;threatening Hamish with prison ; when there letting thugs out as theres no room ; i wish i was younger id be out of this cesspit we call GREAT BRITAIN ; IT WOULD BE LAUGHABLE IF IT WASNT SO TRAGIC
6

ScotthatesBlackpoolCouncil,

South shore 27/03/2008 10:27:26
Every couple of weeks we hear about "Good old Hamish" who is standing up for something that he believes in. Why is it when people do this regarding real issues they get condemed? Why are the government so for a smoking ban when there are more serious issues that they should be dealing with. There are murderers, peodophiles, drug users and abusers walking the streets because our government are too scared to implement tougher laws so these people who commit REAL crimes are out walking are streets after getting a slap on the wrist and the government turns a blind eye but if you (a) stand up for something you believe in and (b) smoke in a public place you get continually fined and taken to court god knows how many times. Id like to see the government actually fighting against any one of the above and crime rates might just fall.
7

Tone from Thornton,

Thornton 27/03/2008 10:51:31
Fact! smoking is a dirty disgusting habit, Its anti-social and wrong that other people should suffer because an individual wants to smoke and contaminate the air they inhale.
I drink and eat out more now in pubs because I don't return home stinking of nicotine and smoke.
I agree that people have the right to smoke, but don't let your dirty habit affect me ok.
The fact this guy was fined I think is good but it could be better if the amount was much greater, say £5000, maybe then this would encourage him to think again.
8

,

27/03/2008 11:11:18
Comment Reported Unsuitable By User
9

bevkeenan,

Blackpool 27/03/2008 11:51:29
Firstly I do not believe in passive smoking, I am a non smoker and just because we are told Roy Castle died of passive smoking we have to believe it, didn't Bruce Forsyth, Ken Dodd and many others worked in smokey atmospheres and are all still alive and kicking in their 80s, I believe if you have a cancer gene it will come out someway, I have rheumatoid arthritis, no one in my family has it, so I must have had the gene. As for Hamish Howitt, I support him wholeheartedly, if all the landlords in Blackpool and elsewhere had an ounce of backbone, this ban would never have come into force, like the poll tax. But instead all the landlords stuck their heads in the sand and called Hamish, now all there pubs are empty and trade is down there screaming, they should have done more before. I believe Hamish Howitt is 100% right in his fight, we are one of the most walked over nations in the world, it won't be long before the government stops fat people eating as it may cost the NHS more for heart problems, we have sat back and allowed a government that doesn't even live with the same rules they dish out to us, and we are suppose to roll over and do nothing, Well I for one won't, I will not be voting Labour or conservative again, they all tell lies. Hamish Howitt will have my vote, and I do not smoke. The Governement wants to stop knife crime, heroin, cannabis, guns, and leave adult smokers alone. The government is breaking Human Rights, do prison officers not have lungs? Why are prisoners allowed to smoke, because it is their Human Rights, and there would be hell to pay if they didn't. In the 2004 White Paper this Government promised non food pubs would be exempt from the smoking ban, if any of you care to look it up. I personally do not like the smell of food in pubs, I also do not like kids in pubs, why can't we have these banned. Has anyone thought of the children whose health is suffering due to mothers and fathers now being prisoners in there own homes as when m
10

bevkeenan,

Blackpool 27/03/2008 11:55:11
added: prisoners in their own home, as before mum used to go to bingo, and dad used to go to his local, now they are sat at home puffing their brains out, so the NHS is still gonna suffer because the next generation is gonna have smoked filled lungs, and they can do nothing about it. All the Government has done is force passive smoking on to young children.... the ones that cannot vote!!!!
Prev
1
2 3 4 5 6 7

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.