Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 3rd September 2010

Council's £70,000 bill for first class trips

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
23 February 2009
BLACKPOOL Council has spent more than £70,000 on first class rail travel in the past 18 months.
The figure – today slammed by one senior councillor as "astonishing" – was revealed amid claims some councillors and senior officers were wasting taxpayers' cash on expensive "jollies" to London.

It is just two weeks since council leader, Peter Callow, ordered a review of all town hall expenditure – including travel.

A first class ticket between Blackpool and London Euston can cost anything up to £300 (off-peak) and £150 (peak) more than a standard fare.

Town Hall bosses have attempted to justify the outlay of £74,000 on first class travel by saying council officers and councillors attending high-level meetings, mainly in London, needed to be able to work on the train.

They said economy class was too disruptive to make that possible.
The Gazette highlights the spending today as part of our It's Your Money campaign to investigate how public cash is spent - and sometimes misspent.

Liberal Democrat councillor and former mayor Robert Wynne said first class tickets should be axed at a time when many taxpayers were struggling to cope during the recession.

He said: "I'm astonished and appalled by the amount being spent on first class rail travel. I don't think the people of Blackpool elected their councillors just so they could go on jollies.

"Every penny of council tax-payers money is vital."

The biggest portion was spent by the Tourism and Regeneration department, which has racked up a £27,693 bill.

Regeneration projects, such as the tram upgrade and the sea defences project together worth £182m, meant more meetings with government in the capital.

The figures show that Coun Ian Fowler, portfolio holder for business services, is the councillor who has made the most first class trips with 30.

Coun Wynne said: "I held the same portfolio as Coun Fowler for four or five years, but I only ever made one first class trip - he has made 30 in 18 months. At the time I did the job, there were big issues to deal with as well with the airport and the sale of Blackpool Zoo."

However, Coun Fowler said he had made a large number of trips because he represents the council on 12 outside bodies, including four which meet in London.

He said: "If people understood the amount of work we have to do, and the papers we have to read and understand, they would realise why we often need to travel first class. Quite often in standard class, you have to stand even if you have a seat booked because someone else has taken it.

"If people think it's not a good use of public money, that's fine, but it may affect the service we can give to the people of Blackpool."

Referring to the latest figures, Coun Callow added: "Many councillors are involved on outside bodies and have to attend meetings elsewhere and they obviously have to travel there but all first class travel is closely monitored and I've ordered a review of all expenditure.

"The decision to continue with first class travel was taken by an all-party members' group which would have included a Liberal Democrat."

The biggest number of first class trips taken by an officer is 55 by Paul Grocott in the tourism and regeneration department.

Executive Director of Business Services Julian Kearsley said Mr Grocott was key to the delivery of the tram upgrade which involved meeting Department of Transport officials in London.

Mr Kearsley said first class travel was closely monitored and in line with national terms and conditions for council officers, and where possible savings are being made.

He said: "Officers need a quiet area where they can go through paperwork and brief themselves ahead of important meetings and that often isn't available in an ordinary carriage.

"We want to get best value for money and you only have to look around the town to see how many big projects Blackpool is involved in at the moment.

"It's key that Blackpool has a voice nationally so we get our fair share of resources."

But Bispham-based Derek Bunting, a member of the Is It Fair? campaign against increases in the council tax, said: "Why travel first class? We have a recession and people are tightening their belts. They could go second class or by a different means to save money.

"The council is not being prudent enough."


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 23 February 2009 8:39 AM
  • Source: n/a
  • Location: Blackpool
 
Prev
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
1

,

23/02/2009 08:54:57
Comment Reported Unsuitable By User
2

CheeseWeasel,

23/02/2009 09:01:49
If I had to travel by rail, I would insist on going first class too. Instead I fly - oh wait I can't fly to London any more...
3

Steven Bate,

Ingthorpe (Bispham) 23/02/2009 09:02:28
They spend all their time & most of our money, going to meetings with LAB/CON Lords and Masters in London. They hold out a large begging bowl for grants and funds for crackpot masterplans. But the Council cannot even organise a few tons of gravel to make the footpaths around Kincraig,s mini lake useable. Even though there are hundreds of tons a week crushed up every week next to the old TVR factory.

There is a serious shortage of brain cells at Blackpool Council.
4

Foxhead,

Blackpool 23/02/2009 09:04:06
Whoops Mr Callow!

Be careful for what you wish for.

You've clearly no idea...........
5

the_saint,

Blackpool 23/02/2009 09:04:57
What Coun Fowler has stated is an insult to all Rail Travellers and stinks of snobbery

As someone who as spent many years travelling to London by Train - I and many others were able to work in economy class.

Also the quote He said: "If people understood the amount of work we have to do, and the papers we have to read and understand, they would realise why we often need to travel first class. Quite often in standard class, you have to stand even if you have a seat booked because someone else has taken it".

If he had booked a seat it is his - end of story. I think mr Fowler is extracting the urine - would he pay to travel first class if he was using his own money? I doubt it!
6

davie@layton,

Blackpool: The Economic Depression ZONE 23/02/2009 09:24:42
Well, well, thats just typical of Councillor Ian Fowlers Tory Attitude. WHAT A Plonker he really is. This shows how much the local conservative party is out of touch with us the PEOPLE. To Quote Cllr Fowler "If people think it's not a good use of public money, that's fine, but it may affect the service we can give to the people of Blackpool." Pray Tell Councillor Fowler how the hell will it effect the service we give the people of the town.

Council PAID EMPLOYEES should not under any circumstances be allowed the "Perks" of first class Travel. I have travelled this route for years standard class and can work on the train perfectly ok. The Goverment have stopped all 1st class travel for civil servants years ago unless extreme security arrangments required them to do so. Is anyone in blackpool council carrying secrets, Nah dont think so.

I Publicly Call upon Councillor Simon Blackburn and the Audit Committee to look into the massive abuse of our tax payers money NOW, not next week, not next month, not next Year NOW. And if there is found to be abuse of this "perk" then the council employees responsible should be held to account for there actions and if required SACKED. No questions asked its legalised theft of our money.

NO DOUBT my comments will be deleted as per normal, freedom of speach my backside.
7

ZimFlyer,

23/02/2009 09:39:15
So davie@layton, are you saying Labour councilors never used first class rail? Lets remember the reason we know about this 70K is the Tories have themselves commissioned this report which I welcome as it means it will force councilors of all parties to becareful with their expenses.

I personally would urge all councilors to use National Express coaches (there is a direct run to London) and perhaps it would force them to push for the Talbot road bus station to be demolished sooner as it's such an embarrasment.
8

Mr_Osato,

23/02/2009 09:40:24
It worries me that one member of staff goes to London 55 times in 18months. That's once every week and a half - surely a bit of common sense and planning could have reduced that number?
9

t_kaay,

blackpool 23/02/2009 09:42:20
What a load of cobblers they are coming out with. I am employed on the trains. The service between Preston and London is a Virgin service. Every train has a quiet coach. All coaches have tables with power points. There is no disruption on these trains (theres no economy class either, its standard) to prevent you working. If someone is sat in your reserved seat you can point this out to them. Surely you have the ability to do that if you can act in public office? This needs to be stopped right now. What a waste of OUR money.
10

Frustrated,

St Annes 23/02/2009 09:57:30
Quite right t-kaay. The Virgin service is very good in standard class and I have always been able to work in it (even in the carriages which aren't mobile phone free). First class is no doubt nicer to be in but when it's public money you should be even more careful when spending it though the opposite seems to be true. If they want to travel first class then they should personally fund the difference in cost.

And unfortunately this is not a Tory issue as some seem to think - you can find examples of public money being used wastefully by all political parties. It's time the public made it quite clear that we won't stand for this whoever is in charge.
Prev
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.